More from the MumsNet thread


I wanted to pull out one or two comments from the MumsNet thread, the first being from page 8.

StewieGriffinsMom Thu 10-Mar-11 18:07:12

The issue of transgendered people I find very interesting because I don’t think they’ve co-opted the medical community. I think they’re being victimised by some of the more heinous aspects/individuals in the medical community; specifically in terms of having to travel overseas to have surgery done at, frankly, dodgy clinics with very high rates of fuck-ups. If they had ‘co-opted’ the medical establishment, more surgeries would be free on the NHS by qualified and competent surgeons. The very fact that they do have to travel to have [affordable] surgeries in places with very poor healthcare suggests to me that it is all about the money and not about the people.

If transgendered people were truly accepted, they would not have statistically higher than average [for women] involvement in the sex industry, high rates of self-harm or suicide nor would they be the butt of jokes in the media.

Like Lenin, the political fall-out of the individual is what bothers me. I do not want, however, for someone who feels they are not alien in their body, to continue to feel that way and I want them to be able to do what is necessary, as individuals, to be happy because everyone deserves this.

Does this make sense?

The first thing I would say to StewieGriffinsMom, regarding the ‘establishment’ support of trans, is that yes they can a lot done on the NHS, but it does vary from place-to-place. See this response from a M2T to another contemplating M2T.

If you ‘go Private’, then yes, you will have to pay. The cost varies depending which surgeon you choose, but is usually in the region of £8-12 000. The main advantage of private treatment is speed; private specialists tend to ‘drag their feet’ less than the NHS centres do.

The NHS will perform this surgery ‘free at the point of delivery’ (you pay for it indirectly through taxes and NI contributions). Where you live will make a difference; Although it’s technically illegal for any PCT to flatly refuse to fund any procedure, they can, and many do, place severe restrictions on how many procedures they’ll fund, and what eligibility criteria they use. The NHS will not (usually; there are some PCTs who will) fund breast augmentation, hair removal, facial surgery and, in many cases, speech therapy; if you need any of these, you’ll have to pay for them privately.

I’m a trans woman, and I work for the NHS.
(posted 2 years ago)

So the bottom line is that a lot of SRS can be done free on the NHS (sometimes dependant on location), but the NHS usually make you wait for years for this stuff after the GID diagnosis. Hence a lot of M2Ts actually opt to go overseas (or pay privately in the UK), because, having lived their lives as men and having more disposable income, they have the dosh at their disposal. So the “poor widdle twanz” argument really does not hold water, considering they have access to funds that most FABs can only ever dream of.

As for the government establishment supposedly not supporting trans, that too is bullshit. In the 60s-70s, it took thousands of women taking to the streets to protest this, across many countries, before the governments reluctantly introduced equal pay legislation. However, 30-40 years later, and FABs are still routinely paid 80 cents to the male dollar. There have been NO mass street demonstrations of trans in the streets to obtain their ‘rights’ to SRS and acknowledgement of their ‘gender’ (sex) status, yet, in twenty seconds or less, trans can get their birth certificates altered, proceedures on the NHS, reallocation to women’s prisons, with trans barely chipping their nailpolish. If that is not catering and supporting trans, I don’t know what is.

As for the “If transgendered people were truly accepted” part, again, this is primarily male violence against trans we are talking about, yet FABs are The Big Meanies in this whole thing. I have said time and time again, I would accept M2Ts in feminism, IF they would support all feminist aims (like reproduction issues) and not try to hijack feminism for their own agenda. Reproductive issues do not concern me personally, but I still fight for the feminist cause in these areas. I would also accept M2Ts in SOME FAB-only spaces, IF they were discriminating as to who comes under the Trans Parasol, but they won’t, nor will they understand that some FAB-only spaces have to be off limits for safety and religious reasons (like Muslim women not being able to share accomodation with unrelated males). But they won’t. They have no concern for FAB safety, and the priorities are all about trans.

As for the high rates in the sex industry, well, GallusMag answered that one beautifully with “Many transgender males work as prostitutes just for the sport of it, not for the money.” Very few (if any) FABs work in prostitution for the ‘sport’, it is for the money.

The self-harm and suicide rates are indicative of not sorting out the root of the problem to begin with. Many M2Ts will suicide AFTER transition/SRS, because gender roles and SRS were not the cause/solution to their problems, it was a bandaid solution that did not address the underlying problems. Some of it is body dysmorphia as well, and non-sexualised body dysmorphia is not treated by indulging the patient in their delusions, it is treated to try and get the patient to see reality and the irrationality of their thoughts. And the meeja make fun of FABs performing femininity all the damn time, so no special snowflake award to be had there.

And finally, I seriously have to ask, why-oh-why, what is ChippedChampagneGlass doing on a site called MumsNet?

ChippedChampagneGlass Sun 13-Mar-11 17:05:45

On the trans rights thing…

I’ll declare a interest – born a boy, now a girl (if that label is right in your 40s…).

Thing is this, if you saw me walking down the street, the chances are you wouldn’t see anything different about me to any other middle aged woman. To that end, why should I be treated differently in any way?

I can’t speak for others, although I would say the militant trans / gender queer folk often scare me, but for me the only use of “rights” is to get functional equality – banking, legal ID and so on. Apart from that I’ll fend for my self like any other woman in the workplace, home and society as a whole? I certainly don’t want any extra rights or privilege, just occasionally I need something thats slightly different to reflect circumstance.

This morning I read a piece in the Telegraph, I think it was yesterdays, about a woman confronting the man who raped her in a car park. It got me thinking again about personal safety. It was ironically about the time rape cropped up on this thread. Sorry if this offends, its not meant to, but the thing is this: I’m “pre op” (ugh horrid term), so suppose I’m am attacked by someone with a knife, the attacker discovers my pre op status, what happens next? I suspect theres a high chance of my being stabbed? I’m not going to say that makes me more vulnerable than any other woman, or gives me special status, God no, I’m just pointing out the twist that can go unmissed. Its a worry I live with.

Are we also supposed to support Stan’s Loretta’s right to have babies, even though he doesn’t have a womb, which is no-body’s fault, not even the Roman’s?

It’s symbolic of his struggle against reality …

To ChippedChampagneGlass I say, plenty of FABs get murdered, just for the ‘privilege’ of being raped (first). Again, no special snowflake award to be had here.

Of course, ChippedChampagneGlass proved my earlier point about all these issues being concerned about trans, and fuck-all to do with FABs.

And no, in your 40s it is not ok to call yourself a girl.

But of course, sakura did a great response to Stan Loretta anyway:

sakura Mon 14-Mar-11 12:28:12

women are killed on a regular basis for having the temerity to exist.

Do you want to know why men attack trans women? Because it reminds them that the sexual hierarchy is fake , that they too, can be fucked/raped by another heterosexual man, and this angers them because that subordinate, debased (in their eyes), status is reserved for women. So when they see a man play acting the female role it reminds them how precarious the whole set-up is. This angers the hell out of them. BUt it doesn’t anger them as much as an actual woman does.

It’s starting to boil down to whether people truly understand what woman-hatred is. “Raping a woman before killing her made you a double veteran” said a Vietnam con. You have to get really knee-deep into the sheer depths if women-loathng that goes on everywhere, before you can make a proper analysis here.

Steth, you have submitted to the trans demand that women be labelled, yet again, as other . It’s not original. Cis-woman, by definition is women in^ ^relation to trans women. Just like women have always been viewed in relation to men.

From Aristotle to Freud men have always viewed women as a negative, a defect, the other, in relation to them, and you are merely continuing this happy patriarchal fallacy by using the term “cis”

As always, see the standard disclaimer and cry me a river.

14 thoughts on “More from the MumsNet thread

  1. jilla

    MtT are in the sex trade because they want to be (unlike the women who are there). They fetishize being raped, abused, degraded and humiliated. Wail he shoved me up against the wall (*ooo nooo tell me more! please!).

    Like

    Reply
  2. Undercover Punk

    I would also accept M2Ts in SOME FAB-only spaces, IF they were discriminating as to who comes under the Trans Parasol, but they won’t

    This KILLS me. WTF is with the queers?? My mom is trans, you know. Everyone is!! YAY!!!

    Ok, so I wouldn’t be totally EXCITED about the vestiges of male privilege in the form of M2T in my FAB-only space (such as the bathroom), but I’d be a lot LESS passionate about the DANGER it poses TO females *IF* there were surgical criteria such that I were reasonably assured that each trans woman’s Great Impregnator* had been ELIMINATED. Naturally, the male social conditioning is not erased from the brain, but at least there would be some MEANINGFUL difference (*to women*) between M2T and MABs.

    As always, biology and social conditioning are TWO SEPARATE issues for females and feminism.

    *h/t to radfemcrafts for that!

    Like

    Reply
  3. Undercover Punk

    what’s the deal my html??1111??!! can you please correct that? Thanks, FAB Lib!!

    >> FL adds: Fixed! It was an errant backslash that got a little too eager and put itself ahead of the pointy bracket!

    Like

    Reply
  4. Sargasso Sea

    We’re ALL tranz now, UP!

    Holy cannoli, I just read a comment *over there* (IBTP is like crack to me these days) wherein a FAB (?) says she spends an hour on her hair and wears all her make up in order “to pass”.

    To pass as what?! A tranz?! Jeezus fuck!

    Like

    Reply
  5. FAB Libber

    Jeezus fuck is right. What the hell is any of that shit doing on what is *supposed* to be a radical feminist blog? A few years ago at IBTW (when it was still IBTP), that shit would have been laughed right out … or spammed.

    Like

    Reply
  6. Undercover Punk

    Oh, thank you!! I do get excited when I’m commenting, you know. 🙂

    Damn, IBTP *is* like crack. It’s wrong. But it’s like a car wreck or something, I can’t look away…

    Like

    Reply
  7. FAB Libber

    Damn, IBTP *is* like crack. It’s wrong. But it’s like a car wreck or something, I can’t look away…

    In the UK they call it rubbernecking when other drivers slow down to look at the wreck. It leads to more accidents. You have been warned 😛

    I think we have officially re-designated the site as IBTW now, thanks to Jilla.
    It’s all our faults, uterine oppression of the uterus-less. Or something.

    Like

    Reply
  8. FAB Libber

    Perhaps we perform uterinetivity out of some sort of cis-supremacy?

    Frankly, we should insist to the govt that all trans ‘gender’ reassignments must include functioning female reproductive systems. The first period should kill off most M2Ts.

    *problem solved*

    And yes, I am evil, now that you ask.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
  9. Sargasso Sea

    Yes, a period is just slightly different than peeing on an old-fashioned sanitary nappy isn’t it?

    For some of us there was all that sexxxay vomiting, diarrhea and clots the size of golf balls to get us in touch with our “femaleness“.

    I’m glad, though, that a PENIS disease required me to surgically remove my cervix/uterus complex because now I can no longer oppress my twanz sistewz with it! And that’s the most important thing, after all.

    Like

    Reply
  10. FAB Libber

    awww Sar, thankfully there are still some of us ACTIVELY OPPRESSING the uterineless twanz zizters with our uteruses and partially working ovaries. In fact, I will as a promise, make up for your now-lack of uterine-power, and OPPRESS for the both of us.

    On a more serious note, yes, decades of menstrual agony did actually make me think of suicide at one point, it was really that bad. Thank gawd for the premature menopause, I earned it.

    But dammit, I shall OPPRESS the uterineless with my super-uterine powers.

    Like

    Reply
  11. ball buster

    I have said time and time again, I would accept M2Ts in feminism, IF they would support all feminist aims (like reproduction issues) and not try to hijack feminism for their own agenda.

    THIS!!^^^

    I totally agree with all your post, but this stood out. Like any other human being with a conscience, I don’t like seeing people hurt, or harassed, or anything like that. They do not give a fuck about reproductive rights or equal pay, because they have those already. Why the fuck do we need them if they don’t? *sarcasm*

    Like

    Reply

Leave a rilly rilly twanzphobic reply, go on, dares ya!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s